Subscribe via RSS Feed

Fact or Fiction?

[ 14 ] 09/08/2009 |

I realize that I’m about to burst everyone’s bubbles here, and I swear I’m not looking to get anyone down.  But there is a myth amongst us, and I cannot let it go any longer.  You need to know that what you have been told is incorrect, so that you can be better educated in your weight loss journeys.

Now, I know you’re all on the edges of your seats wondering what I’m talking about, huh?  I know you are.  I can see you.  (Didn’t you know that we here can see you through your monitors?  Scary, huh?)  I’ll keep you on the edges of your seats no longer.

We’ve all been told that muscle weighs more than fat, right?  Well, friends., I hate to tell you, but it isn’t true.  It is a myth.

Let’s think about this:

Which weighs more?  25 lbs of bricks or 25 lbs of  socks?  They weigh the same, right?

It’s the same with muscle vs. fat.  Muscle doesn’t weigh more than fat, it is just more dense and takes up less space than fat.  That’s why when we work out and gain muscle, we get smaller.

So, now you’re asking, then why if when I do everything right, some weeks I gain weight? It could be water weight.  In fact, most likely, it’s water weight.  Our body weights fluctuate from day to day.  That’s why all of you folks that weigh every day will notice 3-5 lbs in both directions every day.   Water weight can also come from something as simple as eating food with more sodium than you’re used to.  I don’t eat a lot of sodium, so when I do eat something with more sodium, like, ahem, Mexican food, I hold onto that sodium.  And the scales will show it the next day.

Also, our bodies sometimes just need a break.  Losing a significant amount of weight is a real shock to our bodies and sometimes, our bodies just need a breather.  They will do this by holding onto weight or even gaining weight one week.  They just need to take a moment to realize that what we’re doing to them isn’t a bad thing before they go back into loss mode.

What we have to do when we have those weeks we gain is just take a look at everything we’ve done that week.  You may find that you’ll say, “oh…I did have _____ yesterday, and that may be it.”  And if not, then you just have to be patient and wait it out.  If the gain or no loss continues while doing everything right, then you know you have to look further into the situation.

I don’t want you to be discouraged by this.  Exercise is still an essential key to weight loss.  It help us gain muscle which helps speed our metabolisms up, which in turn helps us lose weight.  So, gaining muscle is still a  very good thing.  I want you to gain muscle.  By gaining muscle, you WILL lose weight.  You will get leaner, and you will shrink.  (Isn’t what what we’re all here for anyway?)

Now, as much as you hate to do it….pick up that myth, carry it to your trash can, and throw it away.

Sources:

A 2 Z of Health, Beauty, and Fitness

Personal Body Precision (A lot of other good myths on this one too!)

Weight Watchers

Tags: , , , , , , , , , ,

Category: MIND IT

About april: I'm a brand new cyclist! In just a few short months, the sport has reminded me that it's all about the journey, and I need to enjoy the ride. I live with my two dogs and two birds, and love to spoil my nephew. Oh yeah, and I'm 32. View author profile.

  • http://elfteajusthealthier.blogspot.com/2009/08/ds-challenge-30-days.html Tira

    Wow.

  • http://www.fittothefinish.com/blog Diane Fit to the Finish

    Thanks for blasting this myth. I think that it's really interesting that in my own personal journey to lose 150 pounds there were many short plateaus where I WAS doing all the right things, but the scale wasn't moving.

    I could watch the difference in how my clothes fit, even as I stayed the same on the scale!

  • lucidb

    You're exactly right and I've gone over this with so many people. Volume and weight are confused so often. If you were to scoop out a cup of fat versus a cup of muscle, the muscle would weigh more because of the density you have mentioned. In that way muscle DOES weigh more than fat, but a pound of anything….well it just weighs a pound!

  • http://thesassymama.blogspot.com Heather

    So true! Smarty.

  • http://swanvalleytammi.blogspot.com ValleyGirl

    Sad, but true! Thanks for shedding more light onto why this myth is such a common misconception.

  • http://swanvalleytammi.blogspot.com ValleyGirl

    Deep down, I bet many of us knew this ~ we just didn't want it PROVEN!!! ;) Ah well, it's better to know the ugly truth than to be ignorant.

  • http://www.thekrumwiedesix.blogspot.com Kristin @ OneCrazyMamaof4

    :) Thanks for the info… it is comforting to me also about the water weight etc… for example a few weeks ago when I some how gained 8 stinking pounds in one week… It couldn't possibly have been the ENTIRE bag of sunflower seeds that I consumed in the car in one day while driving across the state ;)

  • Christy_TheSisterhood

    AMEN, Sister. Thanks for clearing that up for me.

  • BrookeF

    i care not about the number on the scale. i care about smaller pants!!

  • http://www.babytealeaves.blogspot.com Christie O.

    yes, thank you for blasting this! in order for everyone here to lose weight, everyone needs the proper tools, i.e. information! arming us with the right information is going to help us move that scale in the right direction!!! and i'm with brooke, i care a little less about the number and a little more about how a suit made of spandex falls on me! hahahaha

  • http://www.losewithlisa.blogspot.com TexasLisa972

    Known about that for a long time, but still like to use the excuse. :)

  • dawnembracingtheordinary

    I have always hated that statement…and have never really believed it myself.

    Weight loss needs to be a balance between healthy eating and healthy excercise.

    I love this group…

  • mitakay

    Look, no lynch mob! ;O) Good post!

  • mitakay

    Look, no lynch mob! ;O) Good post!